CJ Shane - Artist & Writer
  • Home
  • Art
  • Blog
  • Books
  • Events
  • About
  • Contact/Newsletter

Nancy Drew

12/22/2024

5 Comments

 
Picture
 When I was in elementary school, I was a regular visitor to our school library. One day, the librarian pulled me aside and told me that she had a book she thought would interest me. The book was a Nancy Drew Mystery.

I checked out the book, took it home, and started reading it. I was immediately hooked. Not surprisingly, I continued to read mysteries, and by the eighth grade, I had discover Sherlock Holmes. Thanks to the school librarian, this early interest led to a lifetime of finding and reading mysteries, and eventually, to writing them. I still read mysteries, but I also read fiction in most genres except horror. I’m not interested in being scared to death.

The book I read most recently was The Ministry of Time, which is classified as science fiction. But there’s a big romance the develops fairly early in the book. So you could call it a blending of sci fi and romance. However, like any good story, there are mysterious things happening throughout that book that develop eventually into some really suspenseful events. The book has its flaws, but it’s a fun read. I gave it four stars. And while reading it, I thought yet again that just about any good book in any genre has a mystery of some sort at its heart.

Nancy Drew is a teenage amateur sleuth, often accompanied by her two pals Beth and George (really Georgia but everyone calls her George) and Nancy’s boyfriend, Ned. According to the Wikipedia article about Nancy Drew, the books were conceived by Edward Stratemeyer. He wrote plot outlines and then hired Mildred Wirt Benson to ghostwrite the early volumes, using the pseudonym Carolyn Keene. Stratemeyer was the author of the Hardy Boys books for boys, and he created Nancy Drew to appeal to girls. The Nancy Drew stories began to be published in the 1930s. Back then, there seemed to be a stricter division of what boys would like and what girls would like. Or not. These days, romance seems to be the preferred genre for a lot of woman and not so popular with men. On the other hand, men tend to prefer non-fiction, and if they read fiction at all, it will most likely be a sci fi space odyssey or maybe something historical.

Recently I stumbled upon a boxed set of four Nancy Drew stories at Bookman’s book store. I took boxed set home and began reading the first, Without a Trace. The book and characters are as I remember from my childhood. Nancy is a cheerful, curious and tenacious character who won’t quit until she solves the mystery, in this case the theft of an expensive Fabergé egg. The main difference is that the story has been updated to modern times. That means characters engage in web searches, send and receive emails and texts, and, in general, are regular users of digital devices.

The Nancy Drew stories are entertaining, not complex at all, and easy to read. Not surprisingly, Nancy doesn’t take up any difficult issues that we often see in fiction such as poverty, racism, sexism, etc. The books are directed at mostly white, middle-class readers. However, it is worth noting that any active, self-determining and smart female character makes for a good role model for young girls. If you get a chance to read one, please do. I think you’ll enjoy getting to know Nancy and her pals.
​
​Thank you to my school librarian.

5 Comments
Maureen
1/6/2025 03:41:16 pm

I basically learned to read so I could read the “ Cherry Ames” nurse books by Helen Wells that had been my mother’s when she was a child. I quickly graduated to Nancy Drew books, which I adored.
As an adult I was crestfallen to discover that Carolyn Keene was not one person, but several. I don’t know why this disturbed me so much, but it did.

Reply
David Sewell
1/12/2025 02:08:51 pm

I had the exact opposite experience with a librarian and I've never forgotten it. When I was pretty young, maybe in 2nd grade during the early '60s, a bookmobile used to come around to our neighborhood, and one way or another I discovered and started checking out Nancy Drew mysteries--possible the first mysteries I ever read. But after reading maybe two or three, the next time I pulled one off the shelf and handed it to the librarian to check out for me, the librarian was a man. He took the book from me, led me to the Hardy Boys titles, and told me those were the ones I wanted to be reading.

So of course I felt ashamed--obviously I had done something wrong. Probably I never did read another Nancy Drew mystery as a kid. It probably wasn't the only strict enforcement of gender-role expectations I ran into as a young boy, but it sure made an impression.

Reply
shane link
1/16/2025 07:47:38 am

Sorry for the delay in responding.

Maureen, I was surprised to learn so many authors had written the Nancy Drew books...possibly as many as 40!

David, so sorry to learn about your experience. I think the librarian wasn't a professional because librarians are taught in their education to encourage readers, not point them in a direction that would be fit in with the library clerk's view of what is acceptable for a boy or for a girl to read. I hope you were able to find books that you enjoyed, regardless of what that dimwit said to you..

Reply
David Sewell
1/16/2025 08:24:09 am

Given that it was the early '60s, I imagine that the librarian thought that he was doing be a service by keeping me from becoming homosexual, as I clearly would have if I continued reading Nancy Drew. Sigh. (But props to the librarians at the main branch who I remember did let me check out "adult" titles--meaning at the time certainly not porno but anything that might have swear words or references to sex.)

Reply
Shane link
1/16/2025 11:57:28 am

LOL. So reading Nancy Drew could possibly do that? Weird!
I checked out some "adult" books, too, when I was a kid. Like you, there wasn't any porno or anything "steamy," but when I read certain passages about something (?) going on behind closed doors, a lot of questions came into my little kid's head.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    C.J. Shane

    Commentary by artist and writer C.J. Shane. Feel free to comment.

    Archives

    For earlier posts, click on Commentary/Blog 2012-2017

    April 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    June 2024
    December 2023
    December 2022
    March 2022
    January 2022
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    July 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    October 2018
    September 2018

    Categories

    All
    Art & Artists
    Film
    Letty Valdez Mysteries
    Readers
    The World
    Writers And Books

    RSS Feed

© C.J. Shane 2000-2025